Sunday, March 28, 2010
Saturday, March 27, 2010
I had a great opportunity this week to work with a school that had a SMART Table in one of their Special Ed Kindergarten Classrooms.
I’ve seen these at conferences as a DEMO, but have never had the chance to see them in action with kids in a learning situation.
I posted a video of the kids playing with a PAINT program with directions to draw each letter of the alphabet as well as playing a number/word matching game. Both of these activities reinforced learning that had been taking place in this teacher’s classroom.
The kids were pretty well versed in the operation of the table with minimal help from the teacher or me. It made me wonder a few of things, though:
1. This particular tool had what I call a “High Shiny Factor.” It was REALLY cool, and I could see educational uses for it, especially with younger kids. However, it looked like it could easily mask the learning objective with the need to use the tool.
2. It’s like $9,000, which is equal to 2 SmartBoards w/ projectors or 36 Netbook Computers or 45 iPod Touches or 56 Flip Cams or 5 sets of CPS Clickers—you get the point. It’s a lot for one product that has VERY limited functionality. (But, in its defense, what it does, it does well. I just wish it—AND its software—did much more for the money.)
3. I liked the interface, and so did the students, but while it engaged them with technology, the technology itself did not engage a higher cognitive load to do the tasks. There were associated skills that the students had to have in order to operate the table, but they are digital natives, and they were not necessarily working outside their zones.
4. The software was clunky. For a teacher that was familiar enough with the computer, it still seemed like there were a lot of unnecessary steps in order to make it work the right way. In fact, the lesson in the video with math pics and numbers to match took several steps out of the software, utilizing Microsoft Word, Paint, Notebook 10 software, and bringing the results together within the Smart Table software. It was not planning friendly. I don’t know about you, but I do not want to spend 4 hours planning a lesson that will take 30 minutes. And I’m pretty tech savvy.
5. On the upside, the kids really did like it, and it provided opportunities for them to reinforce the learning that had been taking place in their classrooms.
6. What’s really nagging at me is the Super Wow, Creative Lesson that one would have to create in order to make the price worth it. And then, of course, that begs the question of how we would assess the learning that has taken place and determine whether or not the SMART Table contributed to achievement. If this was the miracle tool that turned all the kids into achievement superstars—then I might consider shelling out the $9,000 myself! If, however, the table is going to be a practice tool, or infrequently used (not saying that the teacher I visited is using it infrequently, let me just point out…) I would think there are better investments for technology money—especially in these economic times.
I’m going to try and play with it again. I’m still wrapping my head around developing a strong pedagogical frame around its use. Right now, I’m seeing more play and less learn. I don’t mind the play as long as I can relate it, in a strong and focused way, to thinking and learning.
It was cool, though. (Did I say that already?)
SMART Table Information and Resources from SMART's Website
Friday, March 26, 2010
Thursday, March 25, 2010
Monday, March 22, 2010
Sunday, March 21, 2010
Friday, March 19, 2010
Monday, March 15, 2010
That's okay! I've got a little piece of it to give away!
The vendor area was chock full of great stuff and lots of freebies, which I've got a bag full of to share with you! The conference was a lot of fun with lots of learning and discussion going on. It was a great opportunity to meet online friends face to face, and chance to see some of the heavy hitters in education today! We even got to see Flat Stanley at the Alamo!
So, on with the contest! There are several ways to win, all of which involve visiting one or more of the following...each of which earns you a chance! (Be sure and leave your Twitter username so that I can contact you if you are the winner!)
- Visit my Facebook Page and become a Fan.
- Visit my Consultant Page and leave a comment on the Home Page.
- Leave a comment on my page at ASCD Edge.
- Leave a comment here on this blog, in response to this posting.
- Or send out the following message in its entirety as a tweet: I'm trying to win an #ASCD Bag O' Swag from @fisher1000 #ASCDDigigogyContest
So, what exactly do you win?
Here's a PIC!
- The ASCD Red Bag!
- Preview of Paula Rutherford's new book.
- Flocabulary Sampler
- Pinnacle Learning Sampler
- Silver & Strong Thoughtful Classroom Sample incl. poster
- Mentoring Minds Card Connections Sample
- PBS TeacherLine Laminated Cards
- Free Trial of Education City
We had such a good time in San Antonio--it seemed a shame not to share!
The contest runs through this Friday at 5:00 PM Eastern Time. The Winner will be announced on Twitter and here on the Weblog within this post sometime after 5:00 on Friday! Good luck to everyone!
Oh, and P.S. >>> Winners will be chosen by random by assigning a number to each entry, then using a random number generator to pick the winner!
Sunday, March 14, 2010
Google Fast Flip
tags: google, fastflip, news, toolsPosted from Diigo. The rest of my favorite links are here.
(cross posted from the Curriculum21 Ning)
I’m excited to be presenting this year at the Curriculum Mapping Institute in
Saratoga Springs this Summer. Besides the opportunity for engagement with mapping professionals, I’m looking forward to face to face interactions with my online network. I’m also looking forward to helping to build professional practice around the mapping work that I’m currently doing in school districts.
In my session, Globalizing: Creating Collaborative Experiences to Upgrade Existing Curriculum Maps, we will look at upgrading skills and assessments on already created maps. We will investigate web tools that foster a dynamic and interactive learning experience through collaboration both locally and globally. We will discover together new ways to show evidence of learning in the 21st Century.
In my other session, 21st Century Assessment: Digital Storytelling, we will investigate an array of fun web tools that will invigorate, motivate, and engage the traditional curriculum. We
will create a toolbox of opportunities so that teachers can pick the right tool for students to show evidence of learning, developing a new framework of assessment practices. If you’d like a sneak peek at the Digital Storytelling materials and some examples, CLICK HERE!
Looking forward to seeing everyone!
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Sunday, March 7, 2010
Our Session was entitled Learning For All: Conversations, Collaborations, and Choice Through Technology. Our intention was to showcase collaborative technologies for our participants in an overview session and leave our participants with a playground in which to come back and continue to self-develop at their own paces.
But that’s not what happened.
What happened was better.
We started by engaging the participants in a couple of the technologies we intended to highlight, specifically TodaysMeet and Tweetgrid. The audience conversation quickly turned into one of how to relate these to learning and what their usage might mean for student engagement and achievement. We were still able to show our playground, but we were also able to direct the workshop to the needs of the participants—modeling exactly what should be happening in our classrooms with kids.
We expected learning to take place. But the unexpected happenings raised the level of learning for everyone involved. That was a little slice of awesome.
We were also able to interact with other folks in our network, in real time, via Twitter, Today’s Meet, and Skype, and it made our presentation that much more rich and multi-layered in a way that showed participants exactly how powerful networking and collaboration are.
I’d like to thank the members of our network who were involved in this morning’s session by posting their twitter IDs. There’s no greater group to have in your own networks!
And mine too: @fisher1000
Other links to presentation resources are embedded above, including an archive of our session and resources. Thanks again to all involved this morning. We really showed the power of the network and collaboration!